Writers Workshop: Editors Rock!

English: An icon consisting of a book, a fount...

As as writer, I’m supposed to have an inherent distrust of editors or copy editors. At least, that’s the mythology that has long surrounded writers. In my view, this belief is pure swamp gas. Here’s why.

I’ve had lots of editors and copy editors over the years. This goes back to the time when nothing was electronic. Editing was done by sending manuscripts back and forth in bulky packages. Editors would not only mark up the pages (editor’s marks) but would put colorful stickies or tape all over the place, plus handwritten notes on every margin. It was a huge hassle and, thankfully, the relic of a bygone era. Today, everything is handled electronically – a true blessing for everyone involved.

However, one thing hasn’t changed, and that’s the importance of a great editor or copy editor. A good editor is, and should always remain, a writer’s best friend. Over the years, I’ve had the opportunity to ask for a particular editor for several of my books. She was amazing. She not only found all my errors (and they were legend), she also spotted inconsistencies, failures of logic, screwy descriptions and all other manner of silliness on my part.

I’ve also used editors for Ebook material and similar projects. These folks have also been invaluable, although the work they had to perform was not as onerous as found in traditional publishing. The bottom line, though, remains the same. These E-Editors made all the difference in the final product. They did their job and did it well.


Blue Editors' shirt

The E-Editor I most appreciated is a person whom I never met. It was all handled by E-whatever in the course of E-business. At first, this struck me as a bit strange since I had developed a more personal relationship with traditional editors over the years. However, I checked this person out extensively, contacted clients for whom she had worked, and read everything I could find that even remotely mentioned her name or the name of her business. When I finally approached her with the project, I was pretty confident that she would do a good job.

That first contact made the difference. She responded promptly and in a friendly but professional way. She encouraged me to check on her background before I made my decision (which, unknown to her, passed with flying colors). So, the deal was struck and her work began. In a fair amount of time, and at a fair price, she did a fine job. I found no errors in her work. None.

Would I use this editor again? Of course. I wouldn’t even consider another editor. She has a customer for life because she did everything right.

So, do we love our editors? All together now, “Yes! We love our editors!”

The right editor isn’t a luxury, it’s a necessity for any serious writer.


13 thoughts on “Writers Workshop: Editors Rock!

    • Thanks for your comment. As you can tell, I’ve had some great experiences with editors. One of them (my favorite) was so important to me that I acknowledged her in one of my books, right along with my literary agent and my wife. That’s good company, in my view.

  1. As a writer, editor and author, I agree with everything you’ve said. No matter how good a writer is, they should ALWAYS have an editor. It doesn’t matter who you are. When I hired an editor for my latest book, some people thought I was crazy for paying someone to do a job I have been doing for years. No one is perfect and when reading our own copy, we tend to not see errors as much as a pair of fresh eyes can. Thanks for the post!

  2. Hi Michael. It’s great to meet you! Thank you for stopping by my blog, and now I’m following yours. I’m thrilled to see your work (and you shouldn’t be shy about promoting your books on your blog…that’s part of what they’re for, no?). As a writer, editor, and author, I also agree with all that you’ve said. We all need editors…I’ve even convinced my husband of this (author of 12 books), and he finally let me edit his last two books. Editing is my passion, but then…so is writing. Look forward to exploring all of your blog–you’re an inspiration!

    • Nice to meet you, also. Yep, editors are among my favorite people, as you’ve read. The blog is a labor of love. I’ve had publicists, etc., all my writing life. This place is my “quiet corner” in which I do what I want and interact with my fellow-writers, readers and friends. Call me old school . . . sure old enough.

  3. Pingback: Beware of Snake-Oil Salesmen in the Editing Biz « change it up editing

  4. Pingback: The Importance of An Editor - E-BookBuilders

Have an opinion? Please share it!

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )


Connecting to %s